Obama’s Doctrine of Restraint - The New York Times
- Get link
- X
- Other Apps
One way to define Barack Obama’s foreign policy is as a Doctrine of Restraint. It is clear, not least to the Kremlin, that this president is skeptical of the efficacy of military force, wary of foreign interventions that may become long-term commitments, convinced the era of American-imposed solutions is over, and inclined to see the United States as less an indispensable power than an indispensable partner. He has, in effect, been talking down American power.
President Vladimir Putin has seized on this profound foreign policy shift in the White House. He has probed where he could, most conspicuously in Ukraine, and now in Syria. Obama may call this a form of Russian weakness. He may mock Putin’s forays as distractions from a plummeting Russian economy. But the fact remains that Putin has reasserted Russian power in the vacuum created by American retrenchment and appears determined to shape the outcome in Syria using means that Obama has chosen never to deploy. For Putin, it’s clear where the weakness lies: in the White House.
Russia’s Syrian foray may be overreach. It may fall into the category of the “stupid stuff” (read reckless intervention) Obama shuns. Quagmires can be Russian, too. But for now the initiative appears to lie in the Kremlin, with the White House as reactive power. Not since the end of the Cold War a quarter-century ago has Russia been as assertive or Washington as acquiescent.
Obama’s Doctrine of Restraint reflects circumstance and temperament. He was elected to lead a nation exhausted by the two longest and most expensive wars in its history. Iraq and Afghanistan consumed trillions without yielding victory. His priority was domestic: first recovery from the 2008 meltdown and then a more equitable and inclusive society. The real pivot was not to Asia but to home.
Besides, American power in the 21st century could not be what it was in the 20th, not with the Chinese economy quintupling in size since 1990. The president was intellectually persuaded of the need to redefine America’s foreign-policy heft in an interconnected world of more equal powers, and temperamentally inclined to prudence and diplomacy over force. Republican obstructionism and the politicization of foreign policy in a polarized Washington did not help him. American power, in his view, might still be dominant but could no longer be determinant.
As Obama put it to The New Republic in 2013, “I am more mindful probably than most of not only our incredible strengths and capabilities, but also our limitations.” After Iraq and Afghanistan, giant repositories of American frustration, who could blame him?
But when the most powerful nation on earth and chief underwriter of global security focuses on its limitations, others take note, perceiving new opportunity and new risk. Instability can become contagious. Unraveling can set in, as it has in the Middle East. The center cannot hold because there is none.
“I think Obama exaggerates the limits and underestimates the upside of American power, even if the trend is toward a more difficult environment for translating power and influence,” Richard Haass, the president of the Council on Foreign Relations, told me. “By doing so, he runs the risk of actually reinforcing the very trends that give him pause. Too often during his presidency the gap between ends and means has been our undoing.”
In Afghanistan, in Libya and most devastatingly in Syria, Obama has seemed beset by ambivalence: a surge undermined by a date certain for Afghan withdrawal; a lead-from-behind military campaign to oust Libya’s dictator with zero follow-up plan; a statement more than four years ago that “the time has come” for President Bashar al-Assad to “step aside” without any strategy to make that happen, and a “red line” on chemical weapons that was not upheld. All this has said to Putin and China’s President Xi Jinping that this is a time of wound-licking American incoherence.
Yet Obama does not lack courage. Nor is he unprepared to take risks. It required courage to conclude the Iran nuclear deal — a signal achievement arrived at in the face of a vitriolic cacophony from Israel and the Republican-controlled Congress. It took courage to achieve a diplomatic breakthrough with Cuba. The successful operation to kill Osama bin Laden was fraught with risk. His foreign policy has delivered in significant areas. America has wound down its wars. The home pivot has yielded a revived economy (at least for some) and given all Americans access to health insurance.
Yet the cost of the Doctrine of Restraint has been very high. How high we do not yet know, but the world is more dangerous than in recent memory. Obama’s skepticism about American power, his readiness to disengage from Europe and his catastrophic tiptoeing on Syria have left the Middle East in generational conflict and fracture, Europe unstable and Putin strutting the stage. Where this rudderless reality is likely to lead I will examine in my next column.
Read the whole story
· · ·
Putin: Russian airstrikes in Syria aimed at helping al-Assad regime
CNN - 6 hours ago
(CNN) Vladimir Putin just confirmed what many suspected -- that Russian airstrikes in Syria are meant to bolster President Bashar al-Assad's regime. But exactly how they're doing that remains a point of contention: Are Russians really focused on ...
Did US weapons supplied to Syrian rebels draw Russia into the conflict?
Washington Post - 12 hours ago
BEIRUT — American antitank missiles supplied to Syrian rebels are playing an unexpectedly prominent role in shaping the Syrian battlefield, giving the conflict the semblance of a proxy war between the United States and Russia, despite President Obama ...
Russia Launches New Airstrikes Against Syrian Rebels
Voice of America - 3 hours ago
Russia launched a new aerial bombardment of Syrian rebels Sunday, helping President Bashar al-Assad's government reclaim territory it had lost. Moscow said most of the targets were in Tal Skik, a highland area of Idlib province that had been controlled ...
Syria conflict: Putin defends Russia's air strikes
BBC News - 12 hours ago
President Vladimir Putin has defended Russia's military operations in Syria, saying the aim is to "stabilise the legitimate authority" of Syrian President Bashar al-Assad. Russia wants to "create conditions for a political compromise" in Syria, he told ...
|
Read the whole story
· ·
Putin: Russian airstrikes in Syria aimed at helping al-Assad regime
CNN - 6 hours ago
(CNN) Vladimir Putin just confirmed what many suspected -- that Russian airstrikes in Syria are meant to bolster President Bashar al-Assad's regime. But exactly how they're doing that remains a point of contention: Are Russians really focused on ...
Did US weapons supplied to Syrian rebels draw Russia into the conflict?
Washington Post - 12 hours ago
BEIRUT — American antitank missiles supplied to Syrian rebels are playing an unexpectedly prominent role in shaping the Syrian battlefield, giving the conflict the semblance of a proxy war between the United States and Russia, despite President Obama ...
Russia Launches New Airstrikes Against Syrian Rebels
Voice of America - 3 hours ago
Russia launched a new aerial bombardment of Syrian rebels Sunday, helping President Bashar al-Assad's government reclaim territory it had lost. Moscow said most of the targets were in Tal Skik, a highland area of Idlib province that had been controlled ...
Shiites in Iraq Hailing Putin for Syria Push
New York Times - 11 hours ago
The United States also took the lead more than a year ago to assemble a coalition to conduct airstrikes in Syria and Iraq against the Sunni militants of the Islamic State. But with the struggle against the Islamic State largely stalemated, it is the ...
Putin Says Russia's Campaign in Syria More Effective Than U.S.
Bloomberg - 5 hours ago
Russian President Vladimir Putin defended his air and cruise-missile strikes on terror targets in Syriaas two Saudi Arabian officials softened their government's position on the fate of Bashar al-Assad. Putin discussed his Syria campaign on Sunday ...
Russia limits US options in Syria
Los Angeles Times - 1 hour ago
The Obama administration may be right that Russia's decision to intervene militarily in Syria will backfire against Vladimir Putin. But for now the audacious Russian president has succeeded in altering events in that country's civil war to his ...
Putin: Russian bombs key to Syria political compromise
CBS News - 17 hours ago
BEIRUT - Syrian troops backed by Russian airstrikes advanced against insurgents in the center of the country as President Vladimir Putin defended Moscow's intervention in the ongoing Syrianconflict, saying it would aid efforts to reach a political ...
|
Read the whole story
· · ·
Obama Clashes With Steve Kroft On Putin, Syria In '60 Minutes' Interview
Huffington Post - 9 hours ago
President Barack Obama: Steve, this is why I've been skeptical from the get go about the notion that we were going to effectively create this proxy army inside of Syria. My goal has been to try to test the proposition, can we be able to train and equip ...
Obama tells '60 Minutes' he's going to stay the course on Syria
Washington Post - 12 hours ago
SAN DIEGO — President Obama indicated in an interview with “60 Minutes” that he isn't mulling over any major changes to his approach to Syria following the failure of his administration's plan to train more than 5,000 moderate rebels and the ...
Barack Obama: Vladimir Putin not leading in Syria fight
CNN - 13 hours ago
"If you think that running your economy into the ground and having to send troops in, in order to prop up your only ally is leadership, then we've got a different definition of leadership," Obama told CBS News' Steve Kroft during an interview that ...
Obama defends Syria strategy, criticizes Putin's leadership role
Fox News - 13 hours ago
President Obama on Sunday acknowledged that his efforts to help resolve the Syria crisis have so far failed but defended his strategy and dismissed assertions that Russian President Vladimir Putin is now the dominant world leader. “I didn't say it was ...
Highlights, outtakes from Obama's 60 Minutes interview
CBS News - 13 hours ago
With the end of his second term on the horizon, President Obama spoke to 60 Minutes this week, reflecting on his achievements -- and on the problems not yet solved. At the top of that list is the protracted crisis in Syria, where more than 250,000 ...
Obama's Doctrine of Restraint
International New York Times - 1 hour ago
One way to define Barack Obama's foreign policy is as a Doctrine of Restraint. It is clear, not least to the Kremlin, that this president is skeptical of the efficacy of military force, wary of foreign interventions that may become long-term ...
A '60 Minutes' interview with an unserious President Obama
Fox News - 1 hour ago
President Obama was widely criticized last year after he claimed Russia intervened in Ukraine “not out of strength, but out of weakness” since it was obvious Russian President Putin decided to meddle in Ukraine because he believed President Obama's ...
In '60 Minutes' Interview, Obama Muddles Facts on Ukraine
<a href="http://CNSNews.com" rel="nofollow">CNSNews.com</a> - 4 hours ago
Russian President Vladimir Putin meets in 2013 with then-Ukrainian President Viktor Yanukovich – the man who President Obama in his CBS interview described as 'a corrupt ruler who was a stooge of Mr. Putin.' (AP Photo/Ivan Sekretarev, File).
Obama: Clinton's handling of emails “a mistake”
KLFY - 6 hours ago
The following is a script from “President Obama” which aired on October 11, 2015. Steve Kroft is the correspondent. L. Franklin Devine, Michael Karzis and Maria Gavrilovic, producers. It's been a week of rising tensions in Syria with Russia stepping up ...
Obama: Vladimir Putin Not Leading in Syria Fight
FOX40 - 13 hours ago
Kroft also asked Obama if he had any indication while meeting with Putin at the United Nations General Assembly that Russia was going to launch airstrikes in Syria the following day, to which President Obama answered that there was “pretty good ...
Barack Obama admits failure in Syria as Islamic State runs riot, but denies ...
NEWS.com.au - 11 hours ago
“I didn't say it was going to be done in a year,” Obama said in a US 60 Minutes interview. “Syria has been a difficult problem for the entire world community. What we have not been able to do so far — and I'm the first to acknowledge this — is to ...
Barack Obama: Russia is not challenging US by getting involved in Syrian conflict
New York Daily News - 13 hours ago
President Obama on Sunday rejected the notion that Russia's increased involvement in the Syrian conflict is proof that Vladimir Putin is trying to challenge U.S. world power and trap the nations into some kind of proxy war in the region. “Syria was ...
Obama Pushes Back: "In What Way" Is Putin Challenging Me?
RealClearPolitics - Oct 11, 2015
In an interview which will air in its entirety tonight on CBS's "60 Minutes," President Barack Obamapushes back against the idea that Russian President Vladimir Putin is "challenging" America's leadership in the world. While Obama tries to justify ...
Obama: Russia Is Not Leading Fight In Syria (VIDEO)
Headlines & Global News - 4 hours ago
"If you think that running your economy into the ground and having to send troops in - in order to prop up your only ally - is leadership, then we've got a different definition of leadership," Obama said during the "60 Minutes" interview with Steve ...
Obama right to be cautious on Syria
The Tand <a href="http://D.com" rel="nofollow">D.com</a> - 5 hours ago
WASHINGTON -- Contrary to popular belief, President Barack Obama does have a plan for Syria. It's just not one that promises to have much immediate impact on the course of the brutal civil war. Russian President Vladimir Putin, by contrast, has a plan ...
Obama calls Putin weak, Russian leader won't return favor
Washington Examiner - 13 hours ago
President Obama is lashing out at Russian President Vladimir Putin, saying he is running Russia's "economy into the ground" and struggling "just to barely hold together" his "sole ally." In an interview with CBS' Steve Kroft aired on Sunday, President ...
Obama had a very contentious interview with '60 Minutes'
Business Insider Australia - 10 hours ago
During an interview that primarily covered Obama's foreign policy in the Middle East, correspondent Steve Kroft was combative with Obama, repeatedly asking questions about his strategy on Syria and ISIS and the administration's response to Putin's ...
Obama: 'Yes' I would win if I ran for president again
Washington Examiner - 13 hours ago
President Barack Obama said Sunday he believes he would win if he ran for president again and called his last year of the presidency "bittersweet." "Do you think if you ran again, could run again, and did run again, you would be elected?" asked Steve ...
WATCH: Obama Asks, 'In What Way' Is Putin Challenging My Leadership?
Haaretz - 22 hours ago
President Barack Obama: Syria was Russia's only ally in the region. And today, rather than being able to count on their support and maintain the base they had in Syria, which they've had for a long time. Mr. Putin now is devoting- his own troops, his ...
Obama Says Putin's Syria Strategy Motivated by Weakness
Wall Street Journal (blog) - 13 hours ago
WASHINGTON — President Barack Obama said Russia's nearly two-week-long military offensive in Syria comes from a position of weakness, after his administration was criticized for appearing to be caught flat-footed by Moscow's mobilization. In an ...
Obama: US plans to train Syrian fighters failed
Middle East Monitor - 3 hours ago
The US's “train and equip” programme for Syria “did not work”, President Barack Obama said in a TV interview broadcast yesterday night. Obama said he had been sceptical of the plan to train 5,000 fighters to combat Daesh in Syria but he felt compelled ...
CBS' Kroft To Obama: Putin Is 'Challenging Your Leadership'
Breitbart News - Oct 9, 2015
Obama responded, “So that's leading, Steve? The — so, let me ask you this question. When I came into office, Ukraine was governed by a corrupt ruler who was a stooge of Mr. Putin. Syria was Russia's only ally in the region. And today, rather than ...
Obama, training opposition hard with Assad in power
ANSAmed - 4 hours ago
(ANSAmed) - WASHINGTON, OCTOBER 12 - US President Barack Obama has told CBS in an interview that his objective was to verify whether training and equipping Syria's moderate opposition against ISIS was possible. However, he told the broadcaster, ...
“Overthrow of Assad No Longer Enforceable”. Obama Advisors Recommend US ...
Center for Research on Globalization - Oct 10, 2015
US President Barack Obama seems to have decided to follow this advice. On Friday, the President temporarily suspended a military program worth $500 million, designed to train Syrian fighters, the New York Times reported.This method of warfare has not ...
Obama slaps down '60 Minutes' reporter's claim that Vladimir Putin is ...
Raw Story - 12 hours ago
In a Sunday evening interview with CBS' 60 Minutes, President Barack Obama shot down reporter Steve Kroft's assertion that Vladimir Putin is “showing leadership” in the Middle East by attempting to prop up the regime of Syrian president Bashar al-Assad.
Obama says Putin is desperate
CCT News - 6 hours ago
SAN DIEGO – In an interview on “60 Minutes”, President Barack Obama said his administration was not considering any major shift in its approach to the Syrian crisis. Obama also said that Russia's entry into the Syrian conflict was out of desperation by ...
Obama makes atartling admissions in 60 Minutes interview
American Thinker (blog) - 14 minutes ago
President Obama was visibly annoyed to face persistent questions from CBS's Steve Kroft in a 60 Minutes interview the likes of which the president has not had to endure. At one point, Kroft accusedObama of “filibustering,” a common tactic of his, but ...
Obama's Two-Timing Foreign Policy
RINF Alternative News - 18 hours ago
The mystery of the Obama administration's foreign policy has always been whether President BarackObama has two separate strategies: one “above the table” waving his arms and talking tough like Official Washington's arm-chair warriors do – and another ...
Obama talks Russia's escalation in Syria on "60 Minutes"
CBS News - Oct 9, 2015
Russian military involvement in the war-torn country is one of the topics Steve Kroft asked PresidentObama about in a new interview for "60 Minutes." Kroft joins “CBS This Morning” to discuss their conversation. Watch the full interview Sunday on “60 ...
Obama Tells '60 Minutes' Hillary Clinton Made Email 'Mistake'
treeangle.co.id (subscription) - 12 hours ago
WASHINGTON President Obama on Sunday called Hillary Rodham Clintons use of a private email server a mistake, but said it had not endangered national security and had been ginned-up into a political attack by Republicans eager to keep her from being ...
|
Read the whole story
· · · · · · · · · · · · ·
 The Guardian |
Moscow summons UK attache over claims RAF licensed to down Russian jets
The Guardian An RAF Tornado in Iraq. The Sunday Times said Tornados launching airstrikes on Isis targets in Iraq were using missiles designed for aerial combat. Photograph: EPA. Shaun Walker in Moscow Ewen MacAskill. Monday 12 October 2015 05.01 EDT Last ... Russia summons Britain's military attache over 'RAF permission to shoot down...Telegraph.co.uk Russia summons Britain over RAF's 'permission to down Vladimir Putin's jets'Daily Mail Putin fury over RAF threat to Russian jetsDispatch Times Sky News -RT all 96 news articles » |
- Get link
- X
- Other Apps
Comments
Post a Comment