Ash Carter: It’s Time to Accelerate the ISIL Fight | Vladimir Putin asked Bashar al-Assad to step down - FT | Russia and U.S., While Pushing for Peace Talks, Jockey for Position in Syria - The New York Times | U.S. Begins Enforcing New Visa Rules For Iranians, Iraqis | US East Coast Hunkers Down as Major Snow Storm Looms | Kremlin Denies Putin Asked Assad To Step Down | Putin denies sending spy chief to Syria to ask Assad to step down - The Guardian | Putin’s most aggressive attack dog is unleashed - The Washington Post | The Guardian view on the Litvinenko inquiry: a price must be paid in Moscow - Editorial | Putin ‘Probably Approved’ Litvinenko Poisoning, British Inquiry Says - The New York Times | Mr. Putin and the Poisonous London Tea Party - The New York Times | Getting Away With Murder in London - Haaretz | The Litvinenko Inquiry
Igor Sergun was asked by Vladimir Putin in 2015 to propose to Bashar al-Assad that he step down. The answer was no... | ©Getty Images; AFP/Getty Images
Reviews
Russia and Islam are not Separate
(Published by Gerard Group International, Intel Analyses, Friday, August 31, 2007)
Why Russia backs Al-Qaeda
By Konstantin Preobrazhensky
Americans generally believe that Russia is afraid of Islamic terrorism as much as the U.S.A. They are reminded of the war in Chechnya, the hostage crisis at the Beslan School in 2004 and at the Moscow Theater in 2002, and of the apartment house blasts in Moscow in 1999, where over 200 people were killed. It is clear that Russians are also targets of terrorism today.
But in all these events, the participation of the FSB, Federal Security Service, inheritor to the KGB, is also clear. Their involvement in the Moscow blasts has been proven by lawyer Mikhail Trepashkin, a former FSB Colonel. For this he was illegally imprisoned, and is now suffering torture and deprivation of medical assistance, from which he is not likely to survive.
A key distinction between Russian and American attitudes towards Islamic terrorism is that while for America terrorism is largely seen as an exterior menace, Russia uses terrorism as an object as a tool of the state for manipulation in and outside the home country. Islamic terrorism is only part of the world of terrorism. Long before Islamic terrorism became a global threat, the KGB had used terrorism to facilitate the victory of world Communism.
This leads to the logical connection between Russian and Islamic terrorism. The late Alexander Litvinenko, poisoned in London in November, 2006, told me that his former FSB colleagues had trained famous Al-Qaeda terrorists Ayman Al-Zawahiri and Juma Namangoniy during the 1980s and 1990s. Ayman Al-Zawahiri, one of the world's most wanted terrorists, has been responsible for the murder of U.S. nationals outside the United States. Before his death, Juma Namangoniy (Jumabai Hojiyev), a native of Soviet Uzbekistan, was a right-hand man of Osama bin Laden in charge of the Taliban's northern front in Afghanistan.
In 1996, Alexander Litvinenko was responsible for securing the secrecy of Al-Zawahiri's arrival in Russia, who was trained by FSB instructors in Dagestan, Northern Caucasus, in 1996-1997.
At that time, Litvinenko was the Head of the Subdivision for Internationally Wanted Terrorists of the First Department of the Operative-Inquiry Directorate of the FSB Anti-Terrorist Department. He was ordered to undertake the delicate mission of securing Al-Zawahiri from unintentional disclosure by the Russian police. Though Al-Zawahiri had been brought to Russia by the FSB using a false passport, it was still possible for the police to learn about his arrival and report to Moscow for verification. Such a process could disclose Al-Zawahiri as an FSB collaborator.
In order to prevent this, Litvinenko visited a group of the highly placed police officers to notify them in advance. "If you get information about some suspicious Arabs arriving in the Caucasus, please report it to me before informing your leadership", he told them.
Juma Namangoniy was once a student of the Saboteur Training Center of the First Chief Directorate of the KGB in 1989-91. The school was notorious for the international terrorists who matriculated from it. It now belongs to the FSB, and since only KGB staff officers were allowed to study there, Juma Namangoniy's presence clearly suggests that he was much more than a civil collaborator.
Mohammed Atta, the pilot of the first plane to crash into the World Trade Center on September 11, 2001, had met with a senior Iraqi intelligence agent in Prague, Czech Republic, five months before the attack. But Iraqi intelligence was just a client of Russia's intelligence service. It brings a new understanding to the fact that President Putin was the first foreign President to call President Bush on 9/11. One may conjecture that he knew in advance what was to happen.
Muslim Name and Communist Heart
Tartars have always been patriotic to Russia. Their independent kingdom was conquered by Russia in the 16th century, but their gentry were allowed to join the Russian upper class and enjoy all its privileges. Even today, many Russian families of noble origin have Tartar origins. Russia has a half-millennium of experience in turning conquered Muslim nations into obedient citizens by bribing their elite.
There are many Soviet Muslims, therefore, who seem to face no conflict of spirit. One can be a Muslim in name only, whose heart belongs to Communism. There have been a lot of such people among Russian Muslims, especially among the Tartars. The Soviet Union has typically preferred to appoint them as ambassadors to Muslim countries. Their Muslim names give them a pass to the local society, but their Communist hearts order them to serve world Communism and not the world of Islam.
In the Soviet period, the highest leadership of the Muslim republics like Uzbekistan were unofficially allowed to practice Islam under the guise of folk rites, even though their Russian colleagues were severely reprimanded for participating in such Christian "rites" as Christmas or Easter. Unlike today, Soviet cartoonists were able to mock Islam as they mocked all other religions and it didn't bring any special reaction.
Muslims of the Uzbek and other Central Asian republics' elite joined the KGB intelligence in order to spy on fellow Muslim countries. In the KGB, I have met a lot of such quasi-Muslim officers.
Russia Grows Muslim
Putin continues the traditional Russian policy of giving privileges to the Muslim elite. Today's Russian Minister of Healthcare, Mikhail Zurabov, is a Chechen. His political agenda includes the total destruction of the Russian healthcare system, looking like revenge for the war in Chechnya. Putin shows no concern over that.
Strategically Russia is surrendering to the Muslim world. The Russian population is declining rapidly, being undermined by 70 years of Communist experiment and the cold indifference of post-communist rulers. Annually, Russia is losing 900 thousand people who are being replaced by Muslims from the Caucasus and Central Asia. Islam is now the second-largest religion in Russia, where it may total up to 28 million adherents. Because of this, Russia was able to join the Organization of the Islamic Conference in 2003.
Russia's great qualitative population change represents both a departure from the past and a strengthening link with it. The synergies between the history of Russia's national policies of terrorism and the radical Islamic terrorism that it is spreading around the world are natural partners that may severely impact on America's own future.
Konstantin Preobrazhensky, a former Lt. Colonel in the KGB who defected to the United States in 1993, is an intelligence expert and specialist on Japan, about which he has written six books. His newest book Russian-American, A New KGB Asset will be published in late 2007.
DOC]Russia and Islam are not Separate - WikiLeaks
https://wikileaks.org/.../49591_Russia%20and%20Islam%20ar...
WikiLeaks
Aug 31, 2007 - Why Russia backs Al-Qaeda. By Konstantin Preobrazhensky. Americans generally believe that Russia is afraid of Islamic terrorism as much as ...
Russia and Islam are not Separate: Why Russia backs Al-Qaeda, by Konstantin Preobrazhensky - Google Search
______________________________________________________
- News Roundup and Notes: January 22, 2016 | Just Security
- Today's Headlines and Commentary - Lawfare
- Today's Headlines and Commentary - Lawfare
US
- US East Coast Hunkers Down as Major Snow Storm Looms
- National Review Magazine Tells Conservatives to Shun Trump
- 5 stages of GOP grief: Coming to terms with Donald Trump - CNNPolitics.com
- The Latest: Spacey: Underwood would appreciate US campaign - The Washington Post
- Body Of Missing Boy Found On Woodland Trail
- Russia To Construct American Indian Memorial in Front of U.S. Embassy | Observer
World
- Dozens of Migrants Drown as Refugee Crisis Continues to Flummox Europe - The New York Times
- Islamic State claims responsibility for Cairo attack that killed nine | Reuters
- Biden to Meet With Turkey's Civic Society
- Americans Abducted in Iraq: Top Suspects Named
- Murder Rate Rises in Mexico, While Other Crimes Fall
Russia and Eurasia
- Kremlin Denies Putin Asked Assad To Step Down
- Putin denies sending spy chief to Syria to ask Assad to step down | World news | The Guardian
- Putin’s most aggressive attack dog is unleashed - The Washington Post
- Thousands rally in support of Chechen leader Kadyrov - The Washington Post
- Repression or Reform, Putin Must Decide - Bloomberg View
- Russia's Ruling Regime Must Modernize or Face Collapse | Opinion | The Moscow Times
- Khodorkovsky to Support Russian Opposition Candidates | News | The Moscow Times
- Kudrin Says Russia Can Draw on Well of Social Calm for Two Years - Bloomberg Business
- Davos 2016: Russia Seeks Internal Reforms To Offset Sanctions And Fall In Oil Prices
- Oil Rebound Pulls Ruble Back From Record Lows | News | The Moscow Times
- Facing Oil Price Plunge, Russia Considers Fire Sale of State Companies | News | The Moscow Times
- Thousands Rally in Chechnya In Support of Leader
- Ukraine acts to purge court system of bribery, corruption - Channel NewsAsia
- Window on Eurasia -- New Series: Putin’s Attack on Lenin about the Future Not the Past
- Russia’s Putin Accused Lenin of Ruining the Soviet Union
- Poroshenko Determined Kyiv Will Control Crimea, Separatist Territories
- Flu Virus Is New Killer In Eastern Ukraine
- Ukrainian Hacker Pleads Guilty To Cybercrimes | PYMNTS.com
- Putin sends birthday wishes to Placido Domingo – Slipped Disc
- Forbes | Путин и Ильич: вопросы истории накануне выборов
- Путин исключил ряд чиновников из состава коллегии ВПК | Армия | Общество | Аргументы и Факты
- Opinion: The only way to defeat Putin - EN.DELFI
- За Права Человека |Рамзан Кадыров должен быть немедленно отправлен в отставку | Главные новости дня
- "Русгидро" надеется, что Киргизия возместит потери по соглашению о ГЭС | РИА Новости
- США заподозрили Россию в намерении создать новую авиабазу в Сирии :: Политика :: РБК
- ВЗГЛЯД / Восстановлением отношений Москвы и Токио займется спецпредставитель
- В КПРФ восприняли критику Путина в адрес Ленина как аллегорию
- Financial Times узнала о предложении Путина Асаду уйти в отставку :: Политика :: РБК
- Ъ - Киргизия денонсировала соглашения с Россией о строительстве ГЭС
- Ъ-Новости - Партии «Яблоко» не разрешили провести митинг за отставку Рамзана Кадырова
- Глава РАН рассказал Путину о существенном отставании России в науке :: Общество :: РБК
- Эрдоган намерен обсудить с Байденом отношение Турции к ИГ и РПК | РИА Новости
- Ъ-Новости - Fox News: США опасаются появления новых российских баз в Сирии
- Песков опроверг данные о том, что Путин предлагал Асаду уйти с поста | РИА Новости
- ТАСС: Международная панорама - Министр обороны США заявил о необходимости использовать наземные силы против ИГ
- Политологи: слова Керри о санкциях - позитивный знак РФ и сигнал Киеву | РИА Новости
- Лукашенко: «Последний рубль потратить следует на безопасность народа» - ИА REGNUM
- США отправят сухопутные войска в Сирию и Ирак — Надежда Ермолаева — Российская газета
- США послали "сигнал" Москве: Не исключены "определенные шаги" после доклада об убийстве Литвиненко
- СМИ: В британском докладе по делу Литвиненко нет доказательств вины российских властей
Security
- Ash Carter: It’s Time to Accelerate the ISIL Fight
- Russia and U.S., While Pushing for Peace Talks, Jockey for Position in Syria - The New York Times
- U.S. Begins Enforcing New Visa Rules For Iranians, Iraqis
- Russia Unwilling to Establish Military Communication With NATO
- Russia To Create New Military Divisions In Response To NATO
- Russia to strengthen military in response to NATO expanding drills: agencies | Reuters
- A purge of Putin’s spooks is long overdue | The Times
Litvinenko case
- The Guardian view on the Litvinenko inquiry: a price must be paid in Moscow | Editorial | Opinion | The Guardian
- Putin ‘Probably Approved’ Litvinenko Poisoning, British Inquiry Says - The New York Times
- Mr. Putin and the Poisonous London Tea Party - The New York Times
- Getting Away With Murder in London - Haaretz - Israeli News Source Haaretz.com
- Britain summons Russian envoy to protest killing of ex-KGB spy in London | intelNews.org
- Litvinenko isn't the only Putin critic who ended up dead | GlobalPost
- The horrifying story of another Putin enemy mysteriously poisoned two years before Litvenenko murder
1.21.16 Th
- News Roundup and Notes: January 21, 2016 | Just Security
- DEBKAfile, Political Analysis, Espionage, Terrorism, Security
- DEBKAfile, Political Analysis, Espionage, Terrorism, Security
- Who Really Lost Iraq? - Defense One
- Putin implicated in fatal poisoning of former KGB officer at London hotel - The Washington Post
- UK judge: Putin ‘probably approved’ killing of ex-KGB agent - The Washington Post
- Putin likely OK'd Alexander Litvinenko death, inquiry says - CNN.com
- U.S. prematurely posts new visa rules on embassy websites - POLITICO
- Russian Currency Slumps To New All-Time Low
- Putin 'probably approved' Litvinenko killing: UK inquiry - Yahoo News
- Pakistan Mourns, Buries Victims From University Attack - ABC News
- US announces new visa laws to keep out terrorists | Fox News Video
- ISIS using 'jihotties' to recruit brides for fighters - CNN Video
- May: Litvinenko’s death an unacceptable breach of international law – video | Politics | The Guardian
- An inch of snow, icy roads unleash 9 hours of traffic chaos across D.C. region - The Washington Post
- Israel says will seize West Bank land; demolishes EU structures | Reuters
- IS claims attack on Egypt checkpoint that killed 5 police - The Washington Post
- Timeline of events in Alexander Litvinenko investigation - The Washington Post
- Hillary Clinton: Cure for Citizens United is more democracy - CNN.com
- Key Findings From British Report Into Former Spy's Killing - ABC News
- Husband arrested after pediatrician stabbed to death in mansion | New York Post
- Turkish PM says no role for 'terrorist groups' in Syria talks | Reuters
- Litvinenko’s widow's QC urges Cameron to act against Russia – video | World news | The Guardian
- Russia's Putin 'probably' approved London murder of ex-KGB agent Litvinenko: UK inquiry | Reuters
- UK judge says Putin 'probably approved' poisoning of ex-Russian spy | Fox News
- This Time, Cheaper Oil Does Little for the U.S. Economy - The New York Times
- Why Is It So Difficult for Syrian Refugees to Get Into the U.S.? - The New York Times
- Putin ‘Probably Approved’ Litvinenko Poisoning, British Inquiry Says - The New York Times
- Key Findings From the Litvinenko Report - The New York Times
- Full Report of the Litvinenko Inquiry - The New York Times
- Diplomatic Clash Over Russian Poison Case - Video - NYTimes.com
- America’s Best Days May Be Behind It - The New York Times
Litvinenko and Polonium
- The Litvinenko Inquiry
- Poisoning of Alexander Litvinenko - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
- Poisoning of Alexander Litvinenko - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia:
- 10. Russia and Islam are not Separate: Why Russia backs Al-Qaeda, by Konstantin Preobrazhensky. According to Preobrazhenskiy, "At that time, Litvinenko was the Head of the Subdivision for Internationally Wanted Terrorists of the First Department of the Operative-Inquiry Directorate of the FSB Anti-Terrorist Department. He was ordered to undertake the delicate mission of securing Al-Zawahiri from unintentional disclosure by the Russian police. Though Al-Zawahiri had been brought to Russia by the FSB using a false passport, it was still possible for the police to learn about his arrival and report to Moscow for verification. Such a process could disclose Al-Zawahiri as an FSB collaborator. In order to prevent this, Litvinenko visited a group of the highly placed police officers to notify them in advance."
- Chechen Nuclear Bomb Explodes in Renewed Litvinenko Inquest | Russian and Eurasian Politics Gordon M. Hahn
False flag of Islamic Terrorism
- Russia and Islam are not Separate: Why Russia backs Al-Qaeda, by Konstantin Preobrazhensky - Google Search
- Russia Was Behind 9/11 -Former Soviet Intelligence Officers - Blogs & Discussions - Patriot Action Network
- The Spirit Of Truth Blog: Russia Was Behind 9/11-2
- Konstantin Preobrazhensky - Google Search
- KGB/FSB's New Trojan Horse: Americans of Russian Descent: Konstantin Preobrazhensky, Various, Andy Glad Graphic Design: 9780615249087: Amazon.com: Books
- MUST READ: Muslim terrorism - false flag operation sponsored by Russia | Examiner.com
- Russian FSB Defector Reveals Kremlin Supports ISIS
- Mali hotel attack: The unanswered questions - BBC News
- Russia Is Sending Jihadis to Join ISIS - The Daily Beast
- ________________________________________________
- The Litvinenko Inquiry - The Notable Excerpts
- PP. 32-33
- 3.110 The second of Mr Litvinenko’s very close friends was Akhmed Zakayev. Mr Zakayev
- arrived in London in 2002 and claimed asylum. Like Mr Litvinenko, he was supported
- by Mr Berezovsky. Mr Zakayev was introduced to Mr Litvinenko by Mr Berezovsky,
- and Mr Zakayev subsequently chose to live with his family in a house very close to the
- Litvinenko’s house in Muswell Hill. As Mr Zakayev put it in evidence, “Chechen people
- first choose the neighbour and then they buy the house. That’s exactly what I did.”
- He said that the two families became “very, very big friends, very close friends”, who
- would see each other almost every day.94 Again, it is clear to me that his friendship with
- Mr Zakayev was an important influence on Mr Litvinenko’s life in the years between
- 2002 and 2006. It was during this period, and no doubt a result of this friendship, that
- Mr Litvinenko became increasingly committed to the Chechen cause, a cause for
- which he campaigned publicly. On a more personal level, Mr Litvinenko decided at
- the end of his life to convert to Islam, a process that Mr Zakayev arranged for him on
- his deathbed.
- PP.55-56
- First, in 2003, MrLitvinenko was one of those in MrBerezovsky’s entourage who became
- involved with a man named Mr Terluk. Mr Litvinenko made a lengthy contemporaneous
- statement about these events for the purposes of Mr Berezovsky’s asylum appeal,
- which I have admitted into evidence.19 According to that statement, Mr Terluk claimed
- in 2003 to have been instructed by an official from the Russian Embassy in London
- to conduct what appeared to have been some form of reconnaissance exercise for
- a possible attempt to assassinate Mr Berezovsky, perhaps by poisoning him. I am
- aware that, in more recent years, Mr Terluk has given a very different version of these
- events, which was the subject of contested defamation proceedings in the High Court
- in London.20 I should make it clear that, whilst I have read and taken into account
- the findings of Mr Justice Eady in the defamation proceedings, I have not sought to
- investigate the true facts of this episode, which are highly contentious and of only
- peripheral importance to my Terms of Reference.
- 4.26 The second incident that I have in mind took place in October 2004, when the houses
- of both Mr Litvinenko and Mr Zakayev were firebombed, apparently by two Chechen
- men who were in dispute with Mr Berezovsky. The evidence that I have about this
- episode, which is limited, suggests that the dispute had arisen over a payment that
- one of the Chechen men claimed he was owed for a trip to Paris, which he said he
- had made at Mr Berezovsky’s request, in connection with a deal relating to the plans
- for a ‘nuclear suitcase bomb’. [M.N.: See more on this subject: "Chechen Nuclear Bomb Explodes in Renewed Litvinenko Inquest | Russian and Eurasian Politics Gordon M. Hahn"]
- Prior to the firebombing of his house, Mr Litvinenko had
- been attempting to mediate on Mr Berezovsky’s behalf.21
- 4.27 As with the Terluk episode, I am not in a position to make any findings as to the rights
- and wrongs of this episode, which took place more than ten years ago. I refer to the
- two incidents because they do perhaps give a flavour of the life that Mr Litvinenko was
- living, and the risks that he was running, as a member of Mr Berezovsky’s entourage
- during this period.
- PP.62-63
- 4.55 I have referred to Mr Litvinenko’s growing sympathy for the Chechen cause, which
- appears to have started with his experiences in the First Chechen War, and developed
- as a result of his friendship with Mr Zakayev following his arrival in London. The
- evidence is that he took up issues related to Chechen independence and the conduct
- of the Russian authorities in resisting it, and indeed much of his campaigning work
- from London was done via the medium of the Chechenpress website.57
- 4.56 Beyond that, Mr Zakayev gave evidence that, at his request, both Mr Litvinenko and
- Ms Politkovskaya served on a War Crimes Commission that had been established
- under his chairmanship in 2004 by Chechnya’s President Maskhadov. Mr Zakayev
- explained that both took an active part in the Committee’s work of attempting to
- gather evidence of Russian war crimes in Chechnya. Mr Zakayev’s evidence was
- that the fact that Mr Litvinenko and Ms Politkovskaya were serving on the Committee
- was public knowledge, and that, in his view, the Russian military and FSB would
- have been “afraid” that they might have faced charges in an international war crimes
- tribunal as a result of the Committee’s work.58
- P.70
- 4.85 The information that Mr Litvinenko gave to Mr Scaramella included some on what
- might be thought to have been particularly sensitive topics. I will give two examples.
- 4.86 First, Mr Litvinenko made various claims to Mr Scaramella about a man called Semion
- Mogilevich. The written closing submissions served on behalf of Marina Litvinenko
- describe Mr Mogilevich as: “one of Russia’s most notorious [Organised Crime Group]
- leaders. … It is said he is responsible for contract killings and smuggling weapons.” 84
- Mr Mogilevich was, at least at one stage, one of the FBI’s most wanted men.85
- I have seen the text of a speech given by the US Attorney General in 2008 in which
- Mr Mogilevich is said to have, “exert[ed] influence over large portions of the natural
- gas industry in parts of what used to be the Soviet Union.” 86
- 4.87 Mr Litvinenko passed on to Mr Scaramella information about Mr Mogilevich that he
- said had emerged from the transcription of the Kuchma tapes. Mr Litvinenko told
- Mr Scaramella that Mr Mogilevich (whom he described as a “well known criminalterrorist”
- ) was. “in a good relationship with Russian President Putin and most senior
- officials of the Russian Federation”; that Mr Mogilevich and President Putin had,
- “a common cause, in my understanding a criminal cause” ; that Mr Mogilevich was
- an arms dealer who was selling weapons to Al-Qaeda; and that he knew: “beyond
- doubt that Mogilevich is FSB’s long-standing agent and all his actions including the
- contacts with Al-Qaeda are controlled by FSB … For this very reason the FSB is
- hiding Mogilevich from FBI.” These allegations were contained in a written statement
- that Mr Litvinenko sent by fax to the offices of the Mitrokhin Commission.87
- PP.90-91
- 5.22 But as I have already indicated, that is not the end of the matter. Professor Service,
- rightly in my view, identified a further consideration. Even if the strict terms of the 2006
- laws could not be brought to bear against Mr Litvinenko, can it be said that they had a
- subtler, less formal effect of encouraging, or emboldening, or even licensing the FSB
- to take action against Mr Litvinenko and others like him?
- 5.23 Professor Service helpfully put the 2006 laws into their historical context. He referred in
- particular to the public outrage in Russia following the killing of five Russian diplomats
- by a Chechen supporting terrorist group in Iraq, and also to FSB claims in July 2006
- that it had been responsible for the explosion in Ingushetia that had killed Shamil
- Basayev, a leading Chechen terrorist.
- 5.24 Against this backdrop, Professor Service expressed the view that the 2006 amendment
- to the anti-extremist law had an influence going beyond the scope of its black letter
- provisions. In his report he put the matter in this way:
- “The amendment did, however, have a political consequence of importance
- by broadening the spectrum of targets to be pursued by the security agencies.
- Not only out-and-out terrorists were mentioned but ‘extremists’ in general, and
- extremism itself was described only in relation to imprecisely delineated categories
- of activity. The door was left open to brand a large swathe of opponents of Putin
- and his administration as extremists who needed to be eliminated. And terrorism
- and extremism were frequently mentioned in the same breath by Putin and his
- ministers. There was little attempt to make an official distinction between the two
- phenomena that the legislation was directed against. To that extent, there was an
- implicit licensing package for FSB operations abroad as well as in Russia.” 12
- P.95
- 5.36 The accounts that Mr Lugovoy has given raise a straightforward factual issue upon
- which, at least to an extent, his broader allegations of blackmail and complicity in
- murder all rest. That factual issue concerns Mr Litvinenko’s reaction to the reduction
- in the payments that Mr Berezovsky was making to him that, as we have already seen,
- took place in early or mid 2006. What was Mr Litvinenko’s reaction to the reduction
- in payments? Did the two men argue? Was Mr Litvinenko upset, and if so was he
- sufficiently upset to contemplate blackmailing his old friend?
- P.102
- 5.65 Is it possible that the Ivanov report triggered Mr Litvinenko’s killing, or at least had
- some connection with it? One obvious difficulty with this theory is that, on Mr Shvets’
- evidence, Mr Lugovoy only received the report a few weeks before what appears
- to have been the first attempt to poison Mr Litvinenko. Mr Shvets was asked about
- this, but was not shaken from his “positive” belief that the Ivanov report triggered
- an operation to murder Mr Litvinenko. His reasoning, as he explained it to me, was
- that such an operation could have been mounted quickly since the Russian security
- agencies already had access to, and experience in the use of, polonium, as well
- as inside knowledge of Mr Berezovsky’s office, and Mr Lugovoy had easy access
- to Mr Litvinenko. He believed it to be credible, therefore, that the planning for
- Mr Litvinenko’s poisoning had not started until September (and presumably, on his
- reasoning, the end of September) 2006.57 He concluded:
- “… look, before Sasha was poisoned, he had lived in London for several years,
- and over this period, he was consistent in making statements, critical statements,
- against Putin… some of this criticism was very insulting, very personal, and still
- Sasha was alive. Nothing happened. He was alive and well. And suddenly he was
- poisoned. So it leads me to believe that we should be looking for something which
- happened shortly before he was poisoned. Something changed in his life-style
- shortly before he was poisoned, and what changes? It was the fact that he was
- fired by Boris Berezovsky, it was the fact that he got involved in other business
- activities, which leads to the report, et cetera.” 58
- 5.66 In his oral closing submissions on behalf of Marina Litvinenko, Mr Emmerson QC
- described Mr Litvinenko’s action in giving a copy of the Shvets Ivanov report to
- Mr Lugovoy as “a fatal mistake”. Mr Emmerson suggested that a similar significance
- could be placed on the fact that Mr Lugovoy knew from his dealings at RISC that
- Mr Litvinenko had been tasked with investigating Mr Gordeyev, who was, in his words,
- “a high-ranking official in the Russian government”. Mr Emmerson submitted that from
- the moment Mr Litvinenko gave Mr Lugovoy a copy of the Ivanov report:59
- P.103
- “Lugovoy not only knew that Litvinenko had been tasked to produce a devastating
- report on Alexei Gordeyev, and that he had been tasked to produce a devastating
- report which implicated both Ivanov and Putin directly in organised crime, but he
- had a copy of the report in his hands. It can hardly be a coincidence… that two
- months later it was Lugovoy who was chosen to be the man to kill Mr Litvinenko.
- The direct and immediate link to Putin and the Kremlin is just too obvious to ignore.”
- P.212
- 9.24 It follows from this short summary that a theory that Mr Lugovoy and Mr Kovtun killed
- Mr Litvinenko on the orders of one or more members of Russian crime gangs would
- not be implausible.
- 9.25 That theory, however, is not supported by the evidence that is available to me.
- Detective Inspector (DI) Mascall stated that the police investigation has not uncovered
- any evidence linking Mr Mogilevich directly to the poisoning.3 More broadly, none of
- the evidence suggests that Mr Lugovoy and Mr Kovtun were commissioned to kill
- Mr Litvinenko by members of crime gangs. More than that, I am satisfied for reasons
- that I shall describe below that Mr Lugovoy and Mr Kovtun in fact received their
- instructions from another source.
- P.213
- 9.32 The List of Issues was drawn up at an early stage of the inquest proceedings, and
- adopted with only a few changes for the purposes of the Inquiry. As the case developed,
- it became apparent that there was no evidence to support the suggestion that either
- Chechen groups or Mr Talik had been involved in Mr Litvinenko’s death.
- ______________________________________
Comments
Post a Comment