Monday, August 29, 2016

Commentary: Evidence points to another Snowden at the NSA

Commentary: Evidence points to another Snowden at the NSA

1 Share

By James Bamford
In the summer of 1972, state-of-the-art campaign spying consisted of amateur burglars, armed with duct tape and microphones, penetrating the headquarters of the Democratic National Committee. Today, amateur burglars have been replaced by cyberspies, who penetrated the DNC armed with computers and sophisticated hacking tools. 

Where the Watergate burglars came away empty-handed and in handcuffs, the modern- day cyber thieves walked away with tens of thousands of sensitive political documents and are still unidentified.

Now, in the latest twist, hacking tools themselves, likely stolen from the National Security Agency, are on the digital auction block. Once again, the usual suspects start with Russia – though there seems little evidence backing up the accusation. 


In addition, if Russia had stolen the hacking tools, it would be senseless to publicize the theft, let alone put them up for sale. It would be like a safecracker stealing the combination to a bank vault and putting it on Facebook. Once revealed, companies and governments would patch their firewalls, just as the bank would change its combination. 

A more logical explanation could also be insider theft. If that’s the case, it’s one more reason to question the usefulness of an agency that secretly collects private information on millions of Americans but can’t keep its most valuable data from being stolen, or as it appears in this case, being used against us.

In what appeared more like a Saturday Night Live skit than an act of cybercrime, a group calling itself the Shadow Brokers put up for bid on the Internet what it called a “full state-sponsored toolset” of “cyberweapons.” “!!! Attention government sponsors of cyberwarfare and those who profit from it !!!! How much would you pay for enemies cyberweapons?” said the announcement. 

The group said it was releasing some NSA files for “free” and promised “better” ones to the highest bidder. However, those with loosing bids “Lose Lose,” it said, because they would not receive their money back. And should the total sum of the bids, in bitcoins, reach the equivalent of half a billion dollars, the group would make the whole lot public. 

While the “auction” seemed tongue in cheek, more like hacktivists than Russian high command, the sample documents were almost certainly real. The draft of a top-secret NSA manual for implanting offensive malware, released by Edward Snowden, contains code for a program codenamed SECONDDATE. That same 16-character string of numbers and characters is in the code released by the Shadow Brokers. The details from the manual were first released by The Intercept last Friday.

The authenticity of the NSA hacking tools were also confirmed by several ex-NSA officials who spoke to the media, including former members of the agency’s Tailored Access Operations (TAO) unit, the home of hacking specialists.  

“Without a doubt, they’re the keys to the kingdom,” one former TAO employee told the Washington Post. “The stuff you’re talking about would undermine the security of a lot of major government and corporate networks both here and abroad.” Another added, “From what I saw, there was no doubt in my mind that it was legitimate.”

Like a bank robber’s tool kit for breaking into a vault, cyber exploitation tools, with codenames like EPICBANANA and BUZZDIRECTION, are designed to break into computer systems and networks. Just as the bank robber hopes to find a crack in the vault that has never been discovered, hackers search for digital cracks, or “exploits,” in computer programs like Windows. 

The most valuable are “zero day” exploits, meaning there have been zero days since Windows has discovered the “crack” in their programs. Through this crack, the hacker would be able to get into a system and exploit it, by stealing information, until the breach is eventually discovered and patched. According to the former NSA officials who viewed the Shadow Broker files, they contained a number of exploits, including zero-day exploits that the NSA often pays thousands of dollars for to private hacking groups.

The reasons given for laying the blame on Russia appear less convincing, however. “This is probablysome Russian mind game, down to the bogus accent,” James A. Lewis, a computer expert at the Center for Strategic and International Studies, a Washington think tank, told the New York Times. Why the Russians would engage in such a mind game, he never explained.

Rather than the NSA hacking tools being snatched as a result of a sophisticated cyber operation by Russia or some other nation, it seems more likely that an employee stole them. Experts who have analyzed the files suspect that they date to October 2013, five months after Edward Snowden left his contractor position with the NSA and fled to Hong Kong carrying flash drives containing hundreds of thousands of pages of NSA documents. 

So, if Snowden could not have stolen the hacking tools, there are indications that after he departed in May 2013, someone else did, possibly someone assigned to the agency’s highly sensitive Tailored Access Operations.

In December 2013, another highly secret NSA document quietly became public. It was a top secret TAO catalog of NSA hacking tools. Known as the Advanced Network Technology (ANT) catalog, it consisted of 50 pages of extensive pictures, diagrams and descriptions of tools for every kind of hack, mostly targeted at devices manufactured by U.S. companies, including Apple, Cisco, Dell and many others. 

Like the hacking tools, the catalog used similar codenames. Among the tools targeting Apple was one codenamed DROPOUTJEEP, which gives NSA total control of iPhones. "A software implant for the Apple iPhone,” says the ANT catalog, “includes the ability to remotely push/pull files from the device. SMS retrieval, contact-list retrieval, voicemail, geolocation, hot mic, camera capture, cell-tower location, etc.” 

Another, codenamed IRATEMONK, is, “Technology that can infiltrate the firmware of hard drives manufactured by Maxtor, Samsung, Seagate and Western Digital.” 

In 2014, I spent three days in Moscow with Snowden for a magazine assignment and a PBS documentary. During our on-the-record conversations, he would not talk about the ANT catalog, perhaps not wanting to bring attention to another possible NSA whistleblower.

I was, however, given unrestricted access to his cache of documents. These included both the entire British, or GCHQ, files and the entire NSA files.

But going through this archive using a sophisticated digital search tool, I could not find a single reference to the ANT catalog. This confirmed for me that it had likely been released by a second leaker. And if that person could have downloaded and removed the catalog of hacking tools, it’s also likely he or she could have also downloaded and removed the digital tools now being leaked.

In fact, a number of the same hacking implants and tools released by the Shadow Brokers are also in the ANT catalog, including those with codenames BANANAGLEE and JETPLOW. These can be used to create “a persistent back-door capability” into widely used Cisco firewalls, says the catalog. 

Consisting of about 300 megabytes of code, the tools could easily and quickly be transferred to a flash drive. But unlike the catalog, the tools themselves – thousands of ones and zeros – would have been useless if leaked to a publication. This could be one reason why they have not emerged until now.

Enter WikiLeaks. Just two days after the first Shadow Brokers message, Julian Assange, the founder of WikiLeaks, sent out a Twitter message. “We had already obtained the archive of NSA cyberweapons released earlier today,” Assange wrote, “and will release our own pristine copy in due course.” 

The month before, Assange was responsible for releasing the tens of thousands of hacked DNC emails that led to the resignation of the four top committee officials. 

There also seems to be a link between Assange and the leaker who stole the ANT catalog, and the possible hacking tools. Among Assange’s close associates is Jacob Appelbaum, a celebrated hacktivist and the only publicly known WikiLeaks staffer in the United States – until he moved to Berlin in 2013 in what he called a “political exile” because of what he said was repeated harassment by U.S. law enforcement personnel. In 2010, a Rolling Stone magazine profile labeled him “the most dangerous man in cyberspace.” 

In December 2013, Appelbaum was the first person to reveal the existence of the ANT catalog, at a conference in Berlin, without identifying the source. That same month he said he suspected the U.S. government of breaking into his Berlin apartment. He also co-wrote an article about the catalog inDer Spiegel. But again, he never named a source, which led many to assume, mistakenly, that it was Snowden.

In addition to WikiLeaks, for years Appelbaum worked for Tor, an organization focused on providing its customers anonymity on the Internet. But last May, he stepped down as a result of “serious, public allegations of sexual mistreatment” made by unnamed victims, according to a statement put out by Tor. Appelbaum has denied the charges.

Shortly thereafter, he turned his attention to Hillary Clinton. At a screening of a documentary about Assange in Cannes, France, Appelbaum accused her of having a grudge against him and Assange, and that if she were elected president, she would make their lives difficult. “It's a situation that will possibly get worse” if she is elected to the White House, he said, according to Yahoo News.

It was only a few months later that Assange released the 20,000 DNC emails. Intelligence agencies have again pointed the finger at Russia for hacking into these emails. 

Yet there has been no explanation as to how Assange obtained them. He told NBC News, "There is no proof whatsoever" that he obtained the emails from Russian intelligence. Moscow has also denied involvement.  

There are, of course, many sophisticated hackers in Russia, some with close government ties and some without. And planting false and misleading indicators in messages is an old trick. Now Assange has promised to release many more emails before the election, while apparently ignoring email involving Trump. (Trump opposition research was also stolen.)  

In hacktivist style, and in what appears to be phony broken English, this new release of cyberweapons also seems to be targeting Clinton. It ends with a long and angry “final message” against “Wealthy Elites . . . breaking laws” but “Elites top friends announce, no law broken, no crime commit[ed]. . . Then Elites run for president. Why run for president when already control country like dictatorship?”

Then after what they call the “fun Cyber Weapons Auction” comes the real message, a serious threat. “We want make sure Wealthy Elite recognizes the danger [of] cyberweapons. Let us spell out for Elites. Your wealth and control depends on electronic data.” Now, they warned, they have control of the NSA’s cyber hacking tools that can take that wealth away. “You see attacks on banks and SWIFT [a worldwide network for financial services] in news. If electronic data go bye-bye where leave Wealthy Elites? Maybe with dumb cattle?”

Snowden’s leaks served a public good. He alerted Americans to illegal eavesdropping on their telephone records and other privacy violations, and Congress changed the law as a result. The DNC leaks exposed corrupt policies within the Democratic Party.  

But we now have entered a period many have warned about, when NSA’s cyber weapons could be stolen like loose nukes and used against us. It opens the door to criminal hackers, cyber anarchists and hostile foreign governments that can use the tools to gain access to thousands of computers in order to steal data, plant malware and cause chaos.

It’s one more reason why NSA may prove to be one of Washington’s greatest liabilities rather than assets.

(James Bamford is the author of The Shadow Factory: The Ultra-Secret NSA From 9/11 to the Eavesdropping on America. He is a columnist for Foreign Policy magazine.)
Read the whole story

· · · · · · · ·

A Partnership Between Russia and the West? Here's Why It's Not Happening

See also: 

Trump and Russia - July 2016

GOP lawmakers seek information on Team Trump's Russia ties | MSNBC
From Trump to Clinton to Russia: These political cartoons go for the Olympic gold - The Washington Post
Ivanka Trump and Wendi Murdoch go sightseeing in Dubrovnik
Trump adviser Michael T. Flynn on his dinner with Putin and why Russia Today is just like CNN - The Washington Post

Manafort - Kilimkin affair - 8.21.16

8.21.16 - How Putin’s Spies Infiltrated the Trump Campaign | The XX Committee
8.24.16 - Commentary: Evidence points to another Snowden at the NSA | Reuters
Manafort deputy may have had link to Russian intelligence -
8.13.16 - Vladimir Putin Has Already Won Our Election | Observer
7.26.16 - Russia’s Long History of Messing With Americans Minds Before the DNC Hack - The Daily Beast
Manafort’s man in Kiev - POLITICO
Analysis of intelligence expert John Schindler | As Putin spies Trumps campaign infiltrated - policy abroad -
News Reviews and Opinions: "We’re up against “the biggest counterintelligence threat faced by this country since the early Cold War..." - Vladimir Putin Has Already Won Our Election
VENONA - Google Search
Michael Weiss - The Daily Beast
michael weiss articles on russian intelligence - Google Search
Top Trump aide lobbied for Pakistani spy front [Video]
manafort, ISI and jihad - Google Search
manafort, Pakistani ISI and jihad - Google Search
Mystery man: Ukraine's U.S. fixer - POLITICO
Trump’s campaign manager linked to Panama Papers | Fusion
Pakistan behind rise of international Jihadi forces: NYT - The Hindu
Manafort deputy may have had link to...
Manafort deputy may have had link to...
Paul Manafort’s man on the inside: Meduza profiles Konstantin Kilimnik, the right hand of Donald Trump’s former campaign head — Meduza
Rinat Akhmetov - Google Search
Rinat Akhmetov - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Oleg Deripaska - Google Search
Obama’s Russia Delusions and Trump’s | commentary
Donald Trump’s campaign aide Paul Manafort QUITS over allegations about cash payments | Daily Mail Online
Donald Trump exclusive: Russian mob-linked fraudster a 'key player' in presidential hopeful's business ventures
Yes, America Spies Really Think Trump is Putin’s Guy | The XX Committee
August | 2016 | The XX Committee
Category:Russia intelligence operations - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Category:Espionage in the United States - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Category:Espionage by country - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
National security of the United States - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
3 reasons Russia’s Vladimir Putin might want to interfere in the US presidential elections - Vox

Trump urges Russia...

Trump urges Russia to find 'missing' Clinton emails, drawing ire | Reuters
Donald Trump Calls on Russia to Find Hillary Clinton’s Missing Emails - The New York Times
Trump invites Russia to meddle in the U.S. presidential race with Clinton’s emails - The Washington Post
Trump to Russia: Uncover, release deleted Clinton emails - AP
US election: Trump 'encourages Russia to hack Clinton emails' - BBC News
The other remarkable, pro-Russia thing that Donald Trump just said - The Washington Post
Republicans have a problem: Trump-Putin - The Washington Post
After Russia Email Remarks, Democrats Say Trump a Danger on National Security | US News
Donald Trump to Russia: hack and publish Hillary Clinton's 'missing' emails | US news | The Guardian

Trump and Russia: A Threat to National Security?

manafort the kingmaker - Google Search
Manafort The (KGB) Kingmaker - Google Search
Clinton leads Trump by 5 points in Reuters/Ipsos poll | Reuters
national security officials and trump - Google Search
statement by former national security officials - Google Search
A Letter From G.O.P. National Security Officials Opposing Donald Trump - The New York Times
US fears over Donald Trump's connections with Vladimir Putin's Russia
Is Donald Trump Working for Russia? -- NYMag
Why Russia Supports Separatist Movements | NBC Bay Area
Transcript: Donald Trump at the G.O.P. Convention - The New York Times
russia is the greatest threat to US security - Google Search
Transcript: Donald Trump on NATO, Turkey’s Coup Attempt and the World - The New York Times
trump and russia - Google Search
melania trump - Google Search
melania trump and russia - Google Search
Melania Trump's extraordinary journey from Communist's daughter to potential First Lady | Daily Mail Online
trump business interests in russia - Google Search
trump as a threat to national security - Google Search
Trump's NATO comments 'unprecedented' - POLITICO
Donald Trump Sets Conditions for Defending NATO Allies Against Attack - The New York Times
Russia’s ugly treatment of Americans - The Washington Post
Donald Trump: The candidate of the apocalypse - The Washington Post
Lt. Gen. Michael Flynn Appears on ‘Real Time’ and Asks Bill Maher, ‘Why Am I Here?’ | Video |
Lt. General Michael K. Flynn Goes on Real Time, Asks ‘Why Am I Here?’ - YouTube
Michael Flynn - YouTube
Does Trump have enough of the wrecking balls to be The Trump? - Google Search